By Zoe Han
Middle-income consumers are finally starting to feel the squeeze from rising grocery prices.
In fact, for the first time in the past year, middle-income consumers — with a yearly income of $40,000 to $80,000 — recently overtook low-income shoppers as the group most affected by rising grocery prices, according to a report by consumer insights and data company Numerator.
Suburban consumers have also seen higher increases in groceries than urban and rural consumers.
With the rate of inflation rising over the past year, low-income consumers were among those feeling the most impact on their day-to-day grocery budget. Soaring inflation has hit working-class families particularly hard, in part because they spend more of their budgets on food, energy, and housing costs .
But the gap between income groups closed up in the week of May 29 and middle-income consumers were more affected than lower income groups, seeing a 15.2% increase in the average price of their groceries compared to last year. Grocery prices increased 14.6% overall for the same period.
“As inflation puts pressure on household budgets, consumers are changing behaviors by the day,” said Eric Belcher, CEO of Numerator.
“Prices in today’s economy can represent real challenges to middle-class households,” said Darren Seifer, food and beverage industry analyst at The NPD Group. “Their income levels could be too low to afford discretionary purchases, while also too high to qualify for assistance programs like SNAP or WIC.”
“Since food and beverage purchases are a top priority, they might have to make tough decisions about what’s appropriate for their budgets,” he added. “They’ll likely cut back restaurant usage , and while shopping in grocery stores, we could see more of them look for items on sale, purchase less expensive cuts of meat, or look to store brands to manage their food expenditures.”
A CNBC poll released in April said persistent inflation would encourage more Americans with middle incomes — versus those with on lower and higher incomes — to cut back on dining out, cut back on driving and/or cancel a vacation and a monthly subscription. (Lower-income households were defined as those earning below $50,000 a year, middle income between $50,000 and $99,000 a year, and higher incomes those earnings $100,000 and over.)
Higher prices hit big-box stores
The Numerator report, released Thursday, crunched purchase data of 10,000-plus people gathered by Numerator’s mobile-receipt app, Receipt Hog. Analyzing its users’ voluntarily-provided receipts on the app, Numerator looked at the average spend per product across all households and compared data for different demographics.
Middle-income shoppers likely saw higher grocery price increases due to recent price hikes at big-box stores including Target /zigman2/quotes/207799045/composite TGT +1.70% and Walmart /zigman2/quotes/207374728/composite WMT +1.85% , as well as dollar stores, a Numerator spokesperson told MarketWatch.
Target and Walmart both reported significant declines in earnings in the first quarter of 2022, in part because of rising costs on everything from wages to transportation to inventory storage. Walmart said on its most recent earnings call that it would likely pass on more of these costs to consumers, and would raise food prices but reduce prices on general merchandise to compensate.
The Numerator purchase data showed that middle-income shoppers spend more than other income groups on groceries at big-box retailers and dollar stores such as Dollar General /zigman2/quotes/200691429/composite DG +0.57% and Family Dollar.
Target, Dollar General and Family Dollar did not respond immediately to requests for comment.
However, price increases vary by shopping outlet.
Among shopping venues, the “online channel” — which includes online retailers such as Amazon /zigman2/quotes/210331248/composite AMZN +2.07% and Instacart — and the “dollar channel” — which comprises dollar stores — have seen the highest increases in grocery prices: 22.5% for the week ending May 29 versus 19.5% for the same period last year, according to Numerator.
The “club channel,” which Numerator defined as warehouse club chains such as Costco /zigman2/quotes/201191698/composite COST +0.94% and Sam’s Club, continued to see the lowest price increases in groceries among all of the channels, up 6.2% on the year for the week ending May 29, compared to 8.2% for the same period a year ago.
Higher prices can lead lower-income consumers to “trade down,” analysts say, as they make changes to their shopping lists such as as buying chicken instead of beef.
Consumers rating their financial situation as “good” or “very good” hovered at 48.8%, down from 52.3% in early April, while those rating their finances as “poor” or “very poor” rose from 11.6% to 14.9% in the same timeframe, Numerator said.
Walmart CEO Douglas McMillon said on the company’s earnings call in May that consumers were changing their spending habits by cutting back on premium brands . He said consumers were choosing cheaper versions of deli meats, dairy and bacon.