By Joy Wiltermuth
An earlier version of this article incorrectly referred to potential damages in billions. This article has been corrected.
Billions of dollars worth of office buildings, retail centers and apartment buildings in coastal U.S. cities sit in the path of major flooding as sea levels rise, according to a new DBRS Morningstar report.
The credit rating agency looked at a snapshot of roughly 47,000 buildings that it monitors out of the roughly $670 billion commercial mortgage bond market and found nearly 5,000 were at risk of severe or extreme flooding, given the dramatic pace of climate change in recent decades.
All told, it pegged about $539 billion worth of mortgage bond deals rated by the agency as having some exposure to severe or extreme flooding, leaving only a fraction of the market free of the threat.
“Investors and underwriters no longer have the luxury of simply checking if a property is outside of FEMA’s 100-year flood zones and verifying there is some evidence of flood insurance,” Kevin Augustyn and his credit rating team, wrote in a new report.
Instead, the team looked at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s latest projections for sea level s, which point to an additional rise along the U.S. coastline of 10 to 12 inches by 2050, or as much as the total rise measured in the past 100 years.
Flood risks helped inform this map, which shows Miami topping the country with an estimated $1.1 billion in structural damages at risk due to flooding at office, retail and multifamily buildings as sea levels rise, according to the report, which relied on data from Arup and the First Street Foundation.
New York had an estimated $582 million in estimated in flooding damages on the line at similar properties, followed by about $450 million in Pittsburgh, $330 million in Boston and roughly $280 million each in Houston and San Francisco. The total value of the buildings at risk in these cities would be much higher.
“Although not all coastal, Pittsburgh is particularly susceptible to flooding because the city is at the junction of three rivers,” the report said.
Climate change has been rapidly evolving, evidenced by the stunning increase in billion-dollar weather and climate disaster events since the 1980 s, which makes historical data “less accurate,” according to the DBRS Morningstar team.
What’s more, commercial property owners can tap national flood insurance coverage from the Federal Emergency Management Agency of only $500,000 for a building and $500,000 for the building’s contents, according to the report, even though many key properties in big cities have been financed with hundreds of millions of dollars in mortgage debt. The report said additional coverage would need to be purchased in the private insurance markets.
To help investors get a better grip on their potential exposure to rising sea levels, the DBRS Morningstar team found 4,704 buildings at risk of extreme and severe flooding (see chart) in bond deals it rates. The following breaks down exposure by deal type.
While the commercial mortgage bond market finances only a cross-section of the nation’s buildings, the DBRS Morningstar report still provides a grim snapshot of the near unavoidable flooding risks most investors face.
That also isn’t the only risk, particularly with the embrace of flexible work arrangements. Before the pandemic, lenders often pitched “single-borrower” commercial mortgage bond deals to investors as safe-haven investments, in part because they frequently helped fund top real estate owners looking to build, buy or refinance New York City’s priciest office towers.
The pandemic upended that view, with office buildings still only 43% occupied more than two years after the onset of the COVID crisis, according to Kastle Systems’ latest 10-city weekly average.
With that backdrop in cities like San Francisco, lenders and investors have grown increasingly wary about financing office buildings.
Real estate owners also will face sharply higher borrowing costs when their debts come due, with the benchmark 10-year Treasury rate /zigman2/quotes/211347051/realtime BX:TMUBMUSD10Y 0.00% near 3.4% on Tuesday, and with the Federal Reserve expected to pull the trigger on another jumbo rate increase next week in a bid to cool rampant inflation, while risking sparking a potential recession.
U.S. stocks swooned on Tuesday after August inflation data came in hotter than expected, with the Dow Jones Industrial Index /zigman2/quotes/210598065/realtime DJIA +0.45% shedding nearly 1,300 points, the S&P 500 /zigman2/quotes/210599714/realtime SPX -0.03% closing down 4.3% and the Nasdaq Composite Index /zigman2/quotes/210598365/realtime COMP -0.52% tumbling 5.2%. It was the worst daily drop for all three indexes since June 11, 2020, according to Dow Jones Market Data.