Bulletin
Investor Alert

The Conversation Archives | Email alerts

Aug. 6, 2022, 4:35 p.m. EDT

Subsidies for renewable energy often go to the same fossil-fuel companies that are fighting the green-energy transition with their other hand

new
Watchlist Relevance
LEARN MORE

Want to see how this story relates to your watchlist?

Just add items to create a watchlist now:

  • X
    Intel Corp. (INTC)
  • X
    Boeing Co. (BA)
  • X
    Oersted A/S (ORSTED)

or Cancel Already have a watchlist? Log In

By Nathan Jensen, and Isabella Steinhauer

Texas is known for fiercely promoting its oil and gas industries, but it’s also the  No. 2 renewable energy producer  in the country after California. In fact, more than a quarter of all the wind power produced in the United States in 2021 was generated in Texas.

These projects benefit from a lucrative state tax incentive program called  Chapter 313 . That incentive program expires on Dec. 31, 2022, and the rush of applications for wind and solar energy projects to secure incentives before the deadline is providing a rare window into a notoriously opaque industry.

By reviewing the applications and ownership documents, we were able to track who actually builds and owns a large portion of the nation’s renewable energy, when and how those assets change hands, and who ultimately benefits from the tax incentives.

The results might surprise you. The majority of utility-scale solar and wind energy projects in Texas aren’t owned by companies focused on renewable energy—they’re owned by energy companies or utilities that are better known for fossil fuels, including some that have  aggressively opposed renewable energy  and climate policies in other states and nationally.

The policy implications of these findings are complex. While these subsidies might lead some energy companies to reduce their greenhouse-gas emissions, they also can allow energy companies to continue polluting from existing fossil-fuel assets while collecting the subsidy benefits.

A subsidy program that saves companies billions

Chapter 313 limits how much companies have to pay in property taxes for schools if those companies build infrastructure and agree to create jobs. The Texas Legislature passed it in 2001 when a number of large companies, including Intel /zigman2/quotes/203649727/composite INTC -2.31% and Boeing /zigman2/quotes/208579720/composite BA -3.39% , were considering Texas for an investment location.

Companies using this program can  save billions of dollars  in local property taxes. However,  investigations have revealed  high costs per job and minimal requirements for companies. The  state’s school funding system  also suffered.

The program wasn’t renewed, but companies that applied for the incentive by Aug. 1, 2022, could grandfather in their investments for 10 years of tax benefits. That led to the  rush of applications , including for wind and solar projects.

Who’s proposing renewable energy projects?

We reviewed 191  wind and solar project applications  filed in 2022. If built, these projects would almost double  the number of renewable energy projects in Texas .

It is notoriously difficult to track the owners of renewable energy projects in the U.S., because most are structured as  limited liability companies , or LLCs. However, the application for Texas incentives requires not only information on the owner, but also a signature of an individual representative of the owners. That provides a glimpse into the impact that subsidies can have and who benefits.

We found that just over a third—69 out of 191 proposed projects—are owned by renewable energy companies, such as Danish company Ørsted /zigman2/quotes/206971802/delayed DK:ORSTED +1.20% and Recurrent Energy, owned by Canadian Solar /zigman2/quotes/205481506/composite CSIQ +0.03% .

Over half the proposals—101—were submitted by energy companies known more for oil and gas, or utilities with fossil-fuel assets. This includes the renewable energy subsidiaries of oil supermajors such as Total /zigman2/quotes/206172043/delayed FR:TTE +2.05% and BP /zigman2/quotes/202286639/delayed UK:BP +0.24% , and utility owners including EDF /zigman2/quotes/201783867/delayed FR:EDF -0.17% , AES /zigman2/quotes/209256253/composite AES -0.66% and Engie /zigman2/quotes/207568496/delayed FR:ENGI -0.27% , all of which are major global players.

Some project applications came from investment groups such as DeShaw Group, Cardinal Investment Group and Horus Capital. Apex Clean Energy, a renewable energy subsidiary of the major investment manager Ares Management, /zigman2/quotes/202624618/composite ARES -0.80% frequently showed up in applications.

New owners take over

The proposed projects provide a snapshot of the renewable-energy projects’ developers—but what happens after these projects are built?

To figure that out, we also looked at all renewable-energy projects completed in 2020 and 2021 that participated in the Chapter 313 incentive program.

To our surprise, almost half of the projects built in 2020 or 2021 had changed hands by 2022. Some were due to company acquisitions. Many other projects were sold.

/zigman2/quotes/203649727/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 25.77
-0.61 -2.31%
Volume: 43.82M
Sept. 30, 2022 4:00p
P/E Ratio
5.53
Dividend Yield
5.67%
Market Cap
$108.32 billion
Rev. per Employee
$606,061
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/208579720/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 121.08
-4.25 -3.39%
Volume: 8.38M
Sept. 30, 2022 4:00p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
0.00%
Market Cap
$74.42 billion
Rev. per Employee
$427,768
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/206971802/delayed
DK : Denmark: OMX
kr. 607.50
+7.20 +1.20%
Volume: 981,529
Sept. 30, 2022 4:59p
P/E Ratio
27.37
Dividend Yield
2.06%
Market Cap
kr.252.17 billion
Rev. per Employee
kr.14.42M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/205481506/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 37.25
+0.01 +0.03%
Volume: 1.22M
Sept. 30, 2022 4:00p
P/E Ratio
17.68
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$2.39 billion
Rev. per Employee
$467,137
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/206172043/delayed
FR : France: Euronext Paris
48.28
+0.97 +2.05%
Volume: 6.22M
Sept. 30, 2022 5:39p
P/E Ratio
6.77
Dividend Yield
5.59%
Market Cap
€120.81 billion
Rev. per Employee
€2.10M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/202286639/delayed
UK : U.K.: London
433.10 p
+1.05 +0.24%
Volume: 36.08M
Sept. 30, 2022 4:35p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
4.97%
Market Cap
£80.05 billion
Rev. per Employee
£2.35M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/201783867/delayed
FR : France: Euronext Paris
11.89
-0.02 -0.17%
Volume: 3.54M
Sept. 30, 2022 5:35p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
4.88%
Market Cap
€46.28 billion
Rev. per Employee
€664,657
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/209256253/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 22.60
-0.15 -0.66%
Volume: 8.48M
Sept. 30, 2022 4:00p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
2.80%
Market Cap
$15.20 billion
Rev. per Employee
$1.39M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/207568496/delayed
FR : France: Euronext Paris
11.84
-0.03 -0.27%
Volume: 9.76M
Sept. 30, 2022 5:38p
P/E Ratio
4.60
Dividend Yield
7.18%
Market Cap
€28.70 billion
Rev. per Employee
€406,907
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/202624618/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 61.95
-0.50 -0.80%
Volume: 1.42M
Sept. 30, 2022 4:00p
P/E Ratio
39.69
Dividend Yield
3.94%
Market Cap
$18.14 billion
Rev. per Employee
$1.75M
loading...
1 2
This Story has 0 Comments
Be the first to comment
More News In
Economy & Politics

Story Conversation

Commenting FAQs »

Partner Center

Link to MarketWatch's Slice.