Bulletin
Investor Alert
Howard Gold

Howard Gold's No-Nonsense Investing Archives | Email alerts

March 9, 2019, 8:55 a.m. EST

You may soon own more stocks than you’d like in the rigged Chinese market

Investors in funds that track MSCI indexes will soon have more exposure to China stocks and a brutal totalitarian regime

new
Watchlist Relevance
LEARN MORE

Want to see how this story relates to your watchlist?

Just add items to create a watchlist now:

  • X
    iShares MSCI ACWI ETF (ACWI)
  • X
    iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF (EEM)
  • X
    Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF (VWO)

or Cancel Already have a watchlist? Log In

By Howard Gold, MarketWatch


AFP/Getty Images
A protest in New York City against China’s treatment of its Uighur minority population.

Global index provider MSCI recently announced it would quadruple the percentage of China A shares—shares of companies that trade on mainland exchanges like Shanghai and Shenzhen and were previously available only to Chinese investors—in its China, global and emerging market indexes by November 2019.

By then, A shares will have what MSCI calls a 20% “inclusion factor” in its indexes, from 5% now. Even that won’t amount to much right away—roughly 3% of its emerging markets index and less than 1% of its global MSCI All Countries World Index /zigman2/quotes/208607471/composite ACWI -0.78% .

But once some technical and access issues are worked out with Chinese authorities, MSCI wants to ramp up exposure to the world’s second-largest stock market until China A shares and stocks traded in Hong Kong and Taiwan comprise more than 50% of the MSCI EM index. The MSCI ACWI (which includes the U.S.) would also show a big increase in its total China weighting from its current 3.75%.

This could ultimately have a big impact on investors. (Competitor FTSE Russell also is increasing exposure to China A shares to more than 5% of the FTSE Emerging Markets Index by March 2020.) The iShares Emerging Markets Index ETF /zigman2/quotes/201454250/composite EEM -0.57% tracks the MSCI index, while the Vanguard Emerging Markets Index ETF /zigman2/quotes/204649024/composite VWO -0.37% , the largest emerging markets ETF, and the Vanguard FTSE all-World ex-US ETF /zigman2/quotes/203057966/composite VEU -0.51%  follow FTSE indexes. So if you’re a global ETF investor, chances are that within a few years, you’ll own a lot more Chinese stocks, whether you want to or not.

Craig Feldman, managing director and global head of index management research at MSCI, told me in an interview that the decision was made after “extensive global consultation” with the firm’s big institutional clients, who, he said, had an “overwhelmingly positive experience” with MSCI’s first expansion of its Chinese holdings last year.

MSCI’s goal, he said, is to create indexes that “make the widest representation…of the market opportunity of China for the international investor.” He sees the firm as a “facilitator of the feedback we get from market participants.” Translation: Wall Street and big institutions are driving this locomotive, and MSCI and FTSE are in the caboose.

The biggest issue, said Feldman, was Chinese stock markets’ lack of accessibility. But negotiations with regulators have opened markets up over the years. “There’s been a strong commitment by Chinese regulators to improve accessibility,” he told me. I get the sense that’s the only thing that really matters to either Wall Street or the index providers.

Never mind that China’s wickedly volatile market is dominated by unsophisticated individuals who regard investing as a form of gambling. They are generally winning this year: the Shanghai Composite Index /zigman2/quotes/210598127/delayed CN:SHCOMP +0.31%   is up 19.1% this year through Friday. And never mind that the Chinese government frequently steps in to prop up share prices or take the wind out of the market’s sails.

And never mind that the A-Share market is dominated by big state-owned enterprises (SOEs) like Sinopec /zigman2/quotes/203060554/delayed HK:338 -0.95%   /zigman2/quotes/200321037/delayed CN:600688 0.00%   /zigman2/quotes/208385578/composite SHI +0.15%  , PetroChina /zigman2/quotes/206980083/delayed CN:601857 -0.19%   /zigman2/quotes/204979431/delayed HK:857 -1.17%   /zigman2/quotes/205108732/composite PTR -0.98%  , and Industrial & Commercial Bank of China /zigman2/quotes/202525815/delayed CN:601398 -0.36%   /zigman2/quotes/201401473/delayed HK:1398 -0.54%  , which are controlled by the Chinese government. Communist Party members even have seats on the boards of directors not only of SOEs but of technology leaders like Tencent /zigman2/quotes/204605823/delayed HK:700 -2.20%   /zigman2/quotes/207908563/delayed TCEHY -1.51%  , Baidu /zigman2/quotes/209050136/composite BIDU -2.01%   and Alibaba /zigman2/quotes/201948298/composite BABA -2.50%  .

But what’s especially striking about this big move is its timing—just as trade tensions between the U.S. and China are high and countries are leery of working with Chinese companies like Huawei Technologies for fear of espionage. And as the Financial Times reported, “Beijing has largely abandoned a list of promised economic liberalization issued four years ago, opting instead for greater control by the party and state over the economy and civil society.”

As President Xi consolidates power—he’s effectively become president for life— China is developing the most technologically advanced surveillance state the world has ever seen . Video cameras track every movement and the secret police or party apparatchiks give every Chinese a “citizen score” which rates how pro- or antisocial they are. Throw in face recognition technology and artificial intelligence and you could have a society that makes Orwell’s 1984 look like a libertarian Utopia.

Finally, in Xinjiang human rights groups estimate the Chinese government has put up to one million Uighur Muslims in “re-education” camps where they are reportedly tortured, have their beards cut, and are even forced to eat pork and drink alcohol , both forbidden by Islam.

This may not matter much to Wall Street and money managers desperate to grab at what may be their last big opportunity, nor to the index providers (Feldman told me it simply wasn’t a focus of the discussions). But it does matter to many investors, especially younger investors who care about the social and environmental impact of their investments. UBS estimates MSCI’s expansions would drive inflows of $67 billion into Chinese markets this year .

Right now, Chinese exposure is minimal in most global and emerging market indexes. But as emerging market funds become China funds, I’d recommend combining a broad developed-market international ETF like iShares Core MSCI EAFE /zigman2/quotes/205252932/composite IEFA -0.48% with a 5%-10% position in a small-cap U.S. growth ETF like iShares S&P Small Cap 600 Growth /zigman2/quotes/209218027/composite IJT -1.09% . Since 2004, it has smoked both th iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF and the S&P 500 /zigman2/quotes/210599714/realtime SPX -1.05%  . It gives you all the rapid growth you’ll need without the currency issues or political headaches of emerging markets—and your money will not finance the rise of Big Brother across the Pacific.

Also read: Why investors need to take care with China’s hot stock market

Howard R. Gold is a MarketWatch columnist. He owns shares in the Vanguard FTSE all-World ex-US ETF. <PHRASE TYPE="COMPANY" SIGNIFICANCE="PROMINENT"> <SYMBOL COUNTRY="US" TICKER="VEU"></SYMBOL> </PHRASE> Follow him on Twitter @howardrgold.

/zigman2/quotes/208607471/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 80.36
-0.63 -0.78%
Volume: 2.49M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:00p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/201454250/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 43.29
-0.25 -0.57%
Volume: 70.55M
Feb. 21, 2020 8:00p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/204649024/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 43.22
-0.16 -0.37%
Volume: 8.10M
Feb. 21, 2020 8:00p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/203057966/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 52.79
-0.27 -0.51%
Volume: 1.89M
Feb. 21, 2020 8:00p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/210598127/delayed
CN : China: Shanghai
3,039.67
+9.52 +0.31%
Volume: 36.46B
Feb. 21, 2020 3:01p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/203060554/delayed
HK : Hong Kong
HK$ 2.09
-0.02 -0.95%
Volume: 5.79M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:08p
P/E Ratio
8.67
Dividend Yield
13.59%
Market Cap
HK$22.84 billion
Rev. per Employee
HK$11.81M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/200321037/delayed
CN : China: Shanghai
¥ 3.69
0.00 0.00%
Volume: 12.08M
Feb. 21, 2020 3:00p
P/E Ratio
17.45
Dividend Yield
6.78%
Market Cap
¥39.94 billion
Rev. per Employee
¥9.97M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/208385578/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 27.02
+0.04 +0.15%
Volume: 23,437
Feb. 21, 2020 6:30p
P/E Ratio
8.78
Dividend Yield
11.92%
Market Cap
$94.30 billion
Rev. per Employee
$1.51M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/206980083/delayed
CN : China: Shanghai
¥ 5.37
-0.01 -0.19%
Volume: 113.82M
Feb. 21, 2020 3:00p
P/E Ratio
23.54
Dividend Yield
3.12%
Market Cap
¥984.65 billion
Rev. per Employee
¥4.49M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/204979431/delayed
HK : Hong Kong
HK$ 3.38
-0.04 -1.17%
Volume: 241.87M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:08p
P/E Ratio
12.97
Dividend Yield
4.66%
Market Cap
HK$625.93 billion
Rev. per Employee
HK$5.32M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/205108732/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 43.38
-0.43 -0.98%
Volume: 76,506
Feb. 21, 2020 6:30p
P/E Ratio
10.03
Dividend Yield
3.90%
Market Cap
$9.24 billion
Rev. per Employee
$678,384
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/202525815/delayed
CN : China: Shanghai
¥ 5.49
-0.02 -0.36%
Volume: 223.71M
Feb. 21, 2020 3:00p
P/E Ratio
6.32
Dividend Yield
4.56%
Market Cap
¥1963.80 billion
Rev. per Employee
¥2.53M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/201401473/delayed
HK : Hong Kong
HK$ 5.52
-0.03 -0.54%
Volume: 197.30M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:08p
P/E Ratio
5.57
Dividend Yield
5.16%
Market Cap
HK$1978.05 billion
Rev. per Employee
HK$3.03M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/204605823/delayed
HK : Hong Kong
HK$ 401.00
-9.00 -2.20%
Volume: 17.45M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:08p
P/E Ratio
39.09
Dividend Yield
0.25%
Market Cap
HK$3885.42 billion
Rev. per Employee
HK$8.27M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/207908563/delayed
US : U.S.: OTC
$ 51.47
-0.79 -1.51%
Volume: 4.10M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:00p
P/E Ratio
39.32
Dividend Yield
0.22%
Market Cap
$499.19 billion
Rev. per Employee
$1.05M
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/209050136/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 129.80
-2.66 -2.01%
Volume: 3.10M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:00p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$36.36 billion
Rev. per Employee
$365,691
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/201948298/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 212.59
-5.45 -2.50%
Volume: 17.70M
Feb. 21, 2020 6:30p
P/E Ratio
25.33
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$584.94 billion
Rev. per Employee
$781,259
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/205252932/composite
US : U.S.: Cboe BZX
$ 64.10
-0.31 -0.48%
Volume: 6.94M
Feb. 21, 2020 4:10p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/209218027/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 196.70
-2.17 -1.09%
Volume: 50,990
Feb. 21, 2020 4:00p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/210599714/realtime
US : S&P US
3,337.75
-35.48 -1.05%
Volume: 2.12B
Feb. 21, 2020 5:16p
loading...

This Story has 0 Comments
Be the first to comment
More News In
Investing

Story Conversation

Commenting FAQs »
Link to MarketWatch's Slice.