By Mark Hulbert
The Italian stock market rose on Monday while the U.K. stock market fell. Italy’s FTSE MIB index /zigman2/quotes/210598024/delayed IT:I945 -1.39% rose 0.92% on the day, while the FTSE U.K. All-Share Index XX:ASX +1.57% was flat.
Is it a coincidence that these returns mirror the outcome of Sunday’s widely-followed European soccer championship match , in which Italy beat England?
Perhaps not. Researchers have found that, as a general rule, a country’s stock market suffers whenever one of its sports teams are eliminated from major world competitions.
Perhaps the best known study on this topic appeared in the August 2007 issue of the . The study, “Sports Sentiment and Stock Returns,” was conducted by finance professors Alex Edmans of the London Business School; Diego Garcia of the University of Colorado Boulder, and Oyvind Norli of the Norwegian School of Management.
After analyzing stock-market reaction to more than 2,000 international sporting events back to 1980, the researchers found that, on average, a given country’s elimination from global competitions was followed by its stock market producing a return that was significantly below average in the immediately subsequent trading session.
Interestingly, the researchers found no corresponding above-average return to a country’s stock market following one of its sports teams’ wins in international competitions. They speculate that this asymmetry traces to a tendency for losing teams’ fans to become more downcast than for winning teams’ fans to become upbeat.
One implication of this asymmetry is that the world equity market will have below-average returns during global sports competitions — during times in which some countries will be eliminated, in other words. Supporting evidence is found in another study, “ Exploitable Predictable Irrationality: The FIFA World Cup Effect on the U.S. Stock Market ,” by Guy Kaplanski of Bar-Ilan University and Haim Levy of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
I note that this implication held true during the last World Cup, which occurred in July 2018. Over the course of that two-week competition, the Vanguard Total World Stock ETF /zigman2/quotes/202040789/composite VT +1.62% lost 0.9%.
What about the Olympics?
This discussion naturally leads to focusing on the upcoming Tokyo Olympics, which kicks off on July 23. In an email, Edmans cautioned against extending his research to this competition. That’s because there is less nationalistic pride at stake in any given event at the Olympics; a country is not “eliminated” if one of its players fails to win a medal, for example.
Sure enough, during the last Olympics, which occurred in August 2016, the Vanguard Total World Stock ETF gained 1.9%.
The investment implication I draw from this body of research: Don’t look for the global stock market to perform better or worse than normal during the upcoming Olympics. That doesn’t mean the market won’t. It just means that if it does, you shouldn’t attribute this result to the Olympics.
There’s a broader investment implication as well: The surprisingly large role our moods play in our investment decisions. We like to think of ourselves as rational investors who approach the markets in a statistically rigorous fashion. These studies on sports sentiment and stock returns show how mistaken we can be.
Spotify’s mood music
As further evidence of how our moods affect our investing, Edmans referred me to a paper he and three colleagues just completed: “ Music Sentiment and Stock Returns Around the World ,” co-authored with Adrian Fernandez-Perez and Ivan Indriawan of the Auckland University of Technology and Alexandre Garel of the Audencia Business School. The study is forthcoming in the Journal of Financial Economics .
The researchers were given access to Spotify Technology /zigman2/quotes/207488629/composite SPOT +1.61% data showing, for each country and each day, the top 200 songs as ranked by the total number of streams. The researchers also had access to the results of a Spotify algorithm that rated each song according to its “valence, or positivity.” They found that “music sentiment is positively correlated with same-week equity market returns” in 40 different countries analyzed.
In other words, listening to upbeat songs can help boost stocks while sadder songs bring the market down.
The researchers are not suggesting that we trade the markets according to which songs are most popular. Rather, their point is to show the importance of immunizing ourselves from the powerful role our moods can otherwise play on our investment decisions.
Perhaps one of the best ways of doing that is to check with a colleague or associate whenever you’re about to make a change to your portfolio. Make sure it’s someone who is not currently experiencing your own sense of exuberance or despondency. You receive a powerful reality check on your emotions from the simple exercise of having to justify your decision to someone else and receiving their feedback.