Bulletin
Investor Alert
Therese Poletti

Therese Poletti's Tech Tales Archives | Email alerts

June 2, 2021, 3:31 p.m. EDT

How much does Apple make from the App Store? Even a landmark antitrust trial couldn’t reveal it

new
Watchlist Relevance
LEARN MORE

Want to see how this story relates to your watchlist?

Just add items to create a watchlist now:

  • X
    Apple Inc. (AAPL)

or Cancel Already have a watchlist? Log In

By Therese Poletti

Even with the profitability of its App Store at the core of the case, the recent antitrust trial between “Fortnite” maker Epic Games Inc. and Apple Inc. couldn’t fully expose how much money flows into Cupertino from apps.

It’s a question that investors would love to know the answer to, because it addresses the entire business model of the App Store. Apple does not disclose any detailed financial results of the App Store, part of a services business that brought in $54 billion in its most recent fiscal year and was hailed as the segment that spurred growth as iPhone sales growth slowed down in recent years.

Don’t miss: The (predicted) Epic vs. Apple verdict is in

The trial offered glimpses of actual numbers on App Store profitability, but it was disputed and the actual numbers were hidden from view. In the second week of the trial, in which the maker of “Fortnite” alleged monopolistic practices by Apple /zigman2/quotes/202934861/composite AAPL +0.15% in federal court in Oakland, Calif., Epic called an expert witness — Ned Barnes of the Berkeley Research Group — to the stand.

Barnes calculated that the App Store had hefty profit margins, which increased to 78% in 2019, up from 75% in 2018, and generated $22 billion in commissions for Apple last year. He was part of a group of economic experts hired by Epic in its quest to prove that Apple’s App Store dominates the market.

Apple disputed that analysis and noted that it spends billions on research and development that are not counted against those profits.

“We invest like crazy in [research and development],” Cook said in his testimony at the end of the trial . He said Apple spent $100 billion since the introduction of the iPhone in 2007, and $50 billion over the past three years. (According to Apple’s last three years of 10-K filings, it was $39.2 billion). He also noted that security and infrastructure costs, in addition to innovative features, cut into its profit margins.

But clearly, Apple did not want Barnes and his testimony heard at all. A few weeks before the trial started, Apple’s attorneys tried to seal the courtroom during his testimony, according to a pretrial motion , because Barnes was relying on “nonpublic, unaudited financial information.” The actual information he studied was not shared in open court, and he was barred from discussing the raw numbers he saw, which were only shared with the judge behind closed doors. Barnes did not respond to a request for comment.

Read also: What each side proved in the historic Apple v. Epic trial

What Apple was willing to say in the courtroom about the App Store’s financials was that its commission, the rate that it charges developers to host an app on its store, has declined over time. The company’s 30% commission does not apply to everyone, and 85% of the apps are free, with no commission, Cook said.

Apple has reported the overall margin on its “services” business since ditching iPhone unit sales from its reports amid a slowdown in unit sales two years ago . The numbers it reports suggests that the fat profit margin Barnes quoted likely isn’t far off — total services margin came in at 70.1% in the most recent quarter, and that includes other businesses that are expected to lose money for Apple right now, such as its music and television streaming services.

During the trial, Apple’s attempts to avoid talking about the billions it takes in from third-party apps were truly laughable. Before Cook’s testimony, Apple’s former marketing chief Phil Schiller was grilled by Epic attorney Katherine Forrest, who openly mocked him when he could not say if the App Store was profitable.

“How is it as the executive responsible for this major business in the country, you don’t know if its profitable?” Forrest asked.

“It’s not what we focus on,” Schiller said. “It doesn’t come up.”

Forrest also reminded him of a press release issued by Apple in 2017 , which stated that software developers earned $70 billion from the App Store since its launch in 2008, which would infer at least $20 billion in profit to Apple. (In court, Apple executives repeatedly referred to the App Store as an “economic miracle” without any sense of irony when they later played dumb about its P&L.)

More from Therese: Apple’s privacy changes are affecting more than just Facebook

With a 30% commission, Apple would have received about $20 billion, she said, which would strongly indicate profitability, but Schiller again said he did not know.

/zigman2/quotes/202934861/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 145.86
+0.22 +0.15%
Volume: 70.44M
July 30, 2021 4:00p
P/E Ratio
28.57
Dividend Yield
0.60%
Market Cap
$2407.45 billion
Rev. per Employee
$1.86M
loading...
1 2
This Story has 0 Comments
Be the first to comment
More News In
Industries

Story Conversation

Commenting FAQs »

Partner Center

About Therese Poletti

RSS News feed

Therese Poletti chronicles the machinations of the technology industry for MarketWatch in the Tech Tales column. Before joining MarketWatch, Poletti covered...

Therese Poletti chronicles the machinations of the technology industry for MarketWatch in the Tech Tales column. Before joining MarketWatch, Poletti covered some of the biggest companies in Silicon Valley for the San Jose Mercury News. Previously, she spent over a decade at Reuters, covering a range of beats, from spot news and Wall Street to biotech and technology. Poletti was also the lead reporter on teams at the Mercury News that won two Society of American Business Editors and Writers awards for breaking news and two Society of Professional Journalist awards. She was also a finalist for the Gerald Loeb Awards in the deadline writing category. Poletti is also the author of "Art Deco San Francisco: The Architecture of Timothy Pflueger," published by Princeton Architectural Press.

More from Therese Poletti

  1. Big Tech is headed for its biggest year yet, and it isn’t even close
  2. Facebook investors, are you starting to see a pattern yet?
  3. Apple’s blowout earnings didn’t help its stock, and here’s why
  4. This could be the peak of the tech boom — Here’s what to look for
  5. Elon Musk says he is done with regular earnings calls. Tesla investors are better off.

Featured Commentary »

Link to MarketWatch's Slice.