Investor Alert

The Conversation Archives | Email alerts

Aug. 6, 2022, 4:35 p.m. EDT

Subsidies for renewable energy often go to the same fossil-fuel companies that are fighting the green-energy transition with their other hand

Watchlist Relevance

Want to see how this story relates to your watchlist?

Just add items to create a watchlist now:

  • X
    Intel Corp. (INTC)
  • X
    Boeing Co. (BA)
  • X
    Oersted A/S (ORSTED)

or Cancel Already have a watchlist? Log In

By Nathan Jensen, and Isabella Steinhauer

1 2

This changed the composition of owners. While renewable energy companies owned roughly half the projects at the application stage, by 2022, two-thirds of the projects were owned by utilities and energy companies with fossil-fuel assets.

The original developers may have benefited from the first year or so of the tax break, but the new owners are poised to reap the majority of the remaining years of the 10-year property-tax incentive.

The most common pattern of sales was a renewable-energy developer selling a project to an energy company or utility. For example, Duke Energy /zigman2/quotes/201480230/composite DUK -0.93% purchased a solar project originally owned by Recurrent Energy, and Alpin Sun sold a solar project to BP.

We found that ownership by self-described “venture capitalists” and other investors was rare before 2022. The lucrative and expiring incentive program likely led to a gold rush of applications, including by some companies with limited experience in renewable energy.

When renewable incentives become subsidies to fossil fuel companies

Many of the owners benefiting from these subsidies have parent companies with  high carbon emissions  and a  history of fighting climate policies .

For example, the company with the most renewable energy projects subsidized under Chapter 313 from 2020 to 2022 is NextEra /zigman2/quotes/200558509/composite NEE +0.13% . NextEra is also the parent company of  Florida Power and Light , a utility that has campaigned against  rooftop solar in Florida  and  sued  to block hydropower imports in Massachusetts. In Texas, however, NextEra lobbied for a continuation of Chapter 313 incentives.

Other major energy companies in the owner list include France’s Total Energy, BP, Duke Energy and Savion, which is owned by Shell /zigman2/quotes/201538663/delayed NL:SHELL -1.93% .

The data suggests some possible tensions within green-energy policy.

Environmentalists have long argued for federal and state subsidies for renewable energy as a means of combating climate change, including in the  climate- and inflation-focused bill currently in Congress .

However, as our data analysis shows, the owners who benefit from renewable-energy incentives can in some cases be the same fossil-fuel companies that actively oppose a green-energy transition.  The results of a 2021 study , using data released by energy companies on earnings calls, also suggest that energy company investments in renewable-energy projects are often simply diversification strategies—they aren’t replacing fossil fuels.

Our analysis is based on one program in Texas, but with the size of the Texas renewable-energy sector, and the companies involved, it can offer insights for broader renewable-energy policies.

Key to any subsidy program is clearly articulating the goals and tracking success in meeting them. If the goal is to reduce greenhouse as emissions, that means examining who is benefiting and determining if the subsidies are actually leading to a transition away from fossil fuels.

Our data begins to shine a light on the answer.

This commentary was originally published by The Conversation—Who benefits from renewable energy subsidies? In Texas, it’s often fossil fuel companies that are fighting clean energy elsewhere

Nathan Jensen is professor of government at The University of Texas at Austin College of Liberal Arts. Isabella Steinhauer is a master’s candidate and graduate research assistant at The University of Texas at Austin College of Liberal Arts.

Get more from MarketWatch

Biden to argue that Manchin-Schumer bill ‘will lower costs’ at event with CEOs, as Senate may be unable pass it this month

Democrats’ climate and tax package would cut deficits by $101.5 billion, CBO estimates

Renewable energy: Strongest ever investment in wind and solar in first half of year even with sting of inflation, supply chains

$ 99.58
-0.93 -0.93%
Volume: 2.64M
Dec. 7, 2022 4:03p
P/E Ratio
Dividend Yield
Market Cap
$77.40 billion
Rev. per Employee
$ 85.29
+0.11 +0.13%
Volume: 5.11M
Dec. 7, 2022 4:00p
P/E Ratio
Dividend Yield
Market Cap
$169.27 billion
Rev. per Employee
NL : Netherlands: Euronext Amsterdam
-0.53 -1.93%
Volume: 13.09M
Dec. 7, 2022 5:35p
P/E Ratio
Dividend Yield
Market Cap
€192.97 billion
Rev. per Employee

1 2
This Story has 0 Comments
Be the first to comment
More News In
Economy & Politics

Story Conversation

Commenting FAQs »

Partner Center

Link to MarketWatch's Slice.