Bulletin
Investor Alert

New York Markets Close in:

April 23, 2021, 4:25 p.m. EDT

Thinking green (investments)? Why it rarely pays to buy niche ‘thematic’ ETFs

new
Watchlist Relevance
LEARN MORE

Want to see how this story relates to your watchlist?

Just add items to create a watchlist now:

  • X
    Tesla Inc. (TSLA)
  • X
    Plug Power Inc. (PLUG)
  • X
    Ballard Power Systems Inc. (BLDP)

or Cancel Already have a watchlist? Log In

By Debbie Carlson

Few investment sectors were hotter last year than electric vehicles, motored by growth in Tesla’s share price.

Fueled by ideas that transportation is on the verge of structural change, investors sought out the next Tesla /zigman2/quotes/203558040/composite TSLA +1.36% . Hydrogen fuel cell producers were one of the beneficiaries in investors’ hunt for another alternative energy emerging technology.

Small companies in the hydrogen-industry space, such as Plug Power /zigman2/quotes/205453512/composite PLUG +2.04% , Ballard Power Systems /zigman2/quotes/205070617/composite BLDP +2.11% and Bloom Energy /zigman2/quotes/209802424/composite BE +4.45% saw valuations skyrocket in 2020 and early 2021.

Exchange traded fund issuers followed the trend, launching two separate ETFs on this niche theme, Defiance Next Gen H2 ETF /zigman2/quotes/225302822/composite HDRO +3.60% and Direxion Hydrogen ETF /zigman2/quotes/225667175/composite HJEN +4.48% in March.

But those ETFs were launched just as demand for growth stocks slumped and as investors started to exit the clean-energy space in the first quarter after 2020’s big run. The hydrogen darlings now sit with valuations down 50% or more.

Shiny new object

Environmental, social and governance (ESG) investors who bought up hydrogen industry stocks last year are now learning a hard lesson, and it’s a reminder that the bright, shiny object can quickly dull. While many analysts are positive on the long-term outlook for electric vehicles and the clean-energy industry, it can take time for investments in a long-term trend to pay off, especially if valuations are high.

Brett Manning, senior market analyst at Briefing.com, says it’s often the case that, once an ETF for a popular theme is created, the stocks that are tracked or selected as part of the portfolio have gone from attractive to expensive. That increases the risk that those rich stocks will give up gains.

A prime example of hyped-up investments that haven’t recouped their initial prices are cannabis ETFs, Manning says. An example is ETFMG Alternative Harvest /zigman2/quotes/204332491/composite MJ +4.25% . The first ETF of its kind, Alternative Harvest debuted in 2015, and its five-year return is down 1.51% according to Morningstar data .

Long-suffering investors

Determining whether an investing theme has staying power takes time, and early investors may suffer losses for a long time. That was the case for clean energy.

Several alternative-energy ETFs launched in the early 2000s in response to crude-oil prices trading well over $100 a barrel. Many closed. The VanEck Vectors Solar Energy ETF debuted in 2008 and ceased trading in 2017.

Only recently have clean-energy ETFs become profitable as the fundamentals of the industry changed, Manning says, pointing to 2020’s popular Invesco Solar ETF /zigman2/quotes/210041821/composite TAN +1.20% as an example. It launched in 2008, and looking at yearly total return for the ETF using Morningstar data , the fund lost money almost annually from 2011 to 2019. In 2019, it rebounded, jumping 66.53%, and the following year it soared 234%. Those mega rallies ended up putting annualized returns in the positive category — the fund now shows a 10-year return of 2.99%.  

Even a diversified global clean-energy ETF such as the 16-year-old Invesco WilderHill Clean Energy ETF /zigman2/quotes/208932878/composite PBW +1.30% suffered losses for much of its existence. Its 15-year return is down 0.8%.

WIZE, WSKY and SLIM

Thematic investing really took off in 2016, with fund issuers using colorful tickers to help them stand out in the crowd. But many closed.

One of the shortest-lived funds was the CrowdInvest Wisdom ETF, which had the ticker WIZE. It launched in April 2016 and closed five months later. It was a smart-beta ETF whose index was composed of U.S.-listed equities weighted by sentiment built by an independent, diverse crowd.

/zigman2/quotes/203558040/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 672.58
+9.04 +1.36%
Volume: 19.63M
May 7, 2021 3:20p
P/E Ratio
672.61
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$639.21 billion
Rev. per Employee
$445,694
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/205453512/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 23.02
+0.46 +2.04%
Volume: 18.96M
May 7, 2021 3:20p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$12.91 billion
Rev. per Employee
N/A
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/205070617/composite
US : U.S.: Nasdaq
$ 15.47
+0.32 +2.11%
Volume: 5.58M
May 7, 2021 3:20p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$4.48 billion
Rev. per Employee
$132,327
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/209802424/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE
$ 23.23
+0.99 +4.45%
Volume: 2.90M
May 7, 2021 3:20p
P/E Ratio
N/A
Dividend Yield
N/A
Market Cap
$3.82 billion
Rev. per Employee
$464,200
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/225302822/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 22.28
+0.78 +3.60%
Volume: 34,553
May 7, 2021 3:03p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/225667175/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 22.06
+0.95 +4.48%
Volume: 9,959
May 7, 2021 3:17p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/204332491/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 21.32
+0.87 +4.25%
Volume: 1.75M
May 7, 2021 3:19p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/210041821/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 75.34
+0.89 +1.20%
Volume: 1.53M
May 7, 2021 3:20p
loading...
/zigman2/quotes/208932878/composite
US : U.S.: NYSE Arca
$ 80.86
+1.04 +1.30%
Volume: 419,282
May 7, 2021 3:20p
loading...
1 2
This Story has 0 Comments
Be the first to comment
More News In
Investing

Story Conversation

Commenting FAQs »

Partner Center

Link to MarketWatch's Slice.